New Horizons Training and Education Blog

 
Kalli Damigou

For years, companies have been obsessed with one question:

How do we stop good people from leaving?

Retention became a KPI.
Turnover became a warning sign.
Exit interviews became strategy documents.

And for good reason.

Losing strong employees is expensive.

But there is another workforce problem that receives far less attention.

One that does not show up in resignation emails.

One that does not trigger a replacement request.

One that may sit quietly inside an organisation for years.

The employee stays.

They attend the meetings.

They answer the emails.

They complete enough work to remain employed.

But somewhere along the way, they have stopped caring.

And increasingly, that may be the bigger problem.


Welcome to the era of “regrettable retention”

Most leaders know the term regrettable attrition.

It describes the employee you genuinely did not want to lose.

But organisations are now confronting its opposite:

regrettable retention.

Gartner recently identified regrettable retention as a major productivity barrier for organisations: the situation where employees remain in the business despite persistent low performance or disengagement, creating a drag on overall workforce productivity.

It is uncomfortable language.

But that is precisely why businesses need to talk about it.

Because employee retention, by itself, is not evidence of organisational health.

Sometimes people stay because they are growing.

Sometimes they stay because they believe in the company.

Sometimes they stay because they have a strong manager, meaningful work and opportunities ahead.

And sometimes?

They stay because leaving feels harder than staying.

Those are very different forms of retention.


The employee who stays can cost more than the employee who leaves

When someone resigns, the cost is visible.

Recruitment.

Onboarding.

Lost knowledge.

Temporary workload pressure.

When someone disengages but stays, the cost is much harder to measure.

It appears gradually.

A little less initiative.

A little less curiosity.

A little more “that’s not my job.”

A little more waiting to be told what to do.

A little less challenge when something clearly is not working.

Eventually, disengagement can become culturally contagious.

The high performer begins wondering why they are carrying more.

The manager spends more time correcting than coaching.

Standards quietly adjust downward.

And what began as one employee problem becomes a team problem.

That is what makes disengagement so dangerous:

it rarely arrives dramatically enough to demand immediate action.


The numbers should worry leaders

According to Gallup’s 2026 global workplace data, only 20% of employees worldwide are engaged at work.

Another 64% are not engaged, while 16% are actively disengaged.

In the United States, engagement fell to 29% in Q3 2026, its lowest level in 15 years.

Those numbers point to a corporate reality that annual engagement surveys can sometimes disguise:

A large percentage of the workforce may technically be present without being psychologically invested.

And “present” and “productive” are not the same thing.


This is not about firing disengaged employees

That would be the lazy interpretation.

Regrettable retention is not an argument for organisations to start removing anyone whose enthusiasm dips.

People disengage for many reasons.

Poor management.

Unclear expectations.

A role that no longer fits.

Lack of recognition.

No visible career path.

Underutilised skills.

Constant restructuring.

Burnout.

A mismatch between what the organisation promised and what employees actually experience.

Sometimes the employee is the problem.

Sometimes the role is the problem.

Sometimes the manager is the problem.

Sometimes the organisation has placed a capable person in an environment where they have almost no reason to perform at their best.

The leadership challenge is knowing the difference.


The most dangerous disengaged employee may be the high performer

There is another form of disengagement that companies often miss entirely.

The employee is still performing.

Their targets are being met.

Their work is good.

Nothing looks wrong.

But emotionally, they have already left.

They stop volunteering ideas.

They stop challenging decisions.

They stop imagining a future inside the organisation.

Their performance remains strong because they are professional, not because they are committed.

This employee is especially dangerous to lose because by the time leadership notices their disengagement, their next job may already be signed.

The warning signs are rarely dramatic.

The person who used to say:

“What if we tried this?”

starts saying:

“Whatever you think.”

That is often more significant than it sounds.


Managers are the early-warning system

Engagement is not primarily an HR programme.

It is a management capability.

Gallup has repeatedly found that managers explain a substantial share of the differences in engagement between teams.

And this makes sense.

Employees experience “the company” largely through everyday interactions with their manager.

Do I know what is expected of me?

Does good work get recognised?

Am I learning anything?

Does someone notice when I am struggling?

Can I see where this role could lead?

Do I feel trusted?

Can I raise a problem without becoming the problem?

No employee engagement campaign can compensate indefinitely for poor answers to those questions.


The real retention question is not “Who stayed?”

It is:

“Who stayed — and what version of them stayed?”

Retention metrics often treat every employee who remains as a success.

But imagine two employees who both stay for another three years.

Employee A is learning faster, taking on greater responsibility, contributing ideas and becoming more valuable.

Employee B has stopped developing, contributes the minimum and has mentally checked out.

On a retention dashboard, both may look identical.

From a business perspective, they are completely different.

That is why organisations need to stop looking at retention in isolation.

Gartner recommends considering both performance and intent to stay, allowing businesses to distinguish different workforce profiles and decide where development investment or intervention is most appropriate.

That is a much more useful question than simply measuring turnover.


Not every disengaged employee needs motivation

Some need development.

This distinction matters.

An employee may look disengaged because they have reached the ceiling of what their current role can teach them.

They have been performing the same responsibilities for three years.

The learning curve has flattened.

No new project.

No new skill.

No new responsibility.

No clear next move.

And then the organisation is surprised when their energy disappears.

This is where retention and learning strategy become inseparable.

Sometimes employees do not need another wellbeing initiative.

They need:

a new capability,

a more challenging assignment,

a certification,

exposure to another department,

leadership responsibility,

or a credible pathway to the next stage of their career.

Development tells an employee something important:

We do not only value what you can do for us today. We are investing in what you could become tomorrow.


Internal mobility may matter more than another recruitment campaign

One of the stranger behaviours in corporate talent management is this:

An employee tells the organisation they want to grow.

There is no clear opportunity.

Six months later, they leave.

Then the company spends thousands recruiting externally for a role that the employee might have grown into.

Gartner is now urging organisations to devote significantly more recruiting capacity to internal mobility and to identify employees with the potential to move into emerging roles.

That requires a change in mindset.

Instead of asking:

“Who already has every skill we need?”

companies may need to ask:

“Who already understands our business and has the potential to learn what comes next?”

That is not merely retention.

That is workforce strategy.


And sometimes, yes, the answer is performance management

There is another side to the conversation.

Development cannot become an excuse for avoiding difficult decisions.

Not every performance problem is caused by insufficient training.

Not every disengaged employee wants to re-engage.

Not every role mismatch can be redesigned.

Healthy organisations need both compassion and standards.

Clear expectations.

Honest feedback.

Meaningful development opportunities.

Time to improve.

And accountability when improvement does not happen.

Keeping someone indefinitely because addressing poor performance feels uncomfortable is not kindness.

It shifts the cost onto colleagues who continue to perform.

And eventually, the strongest employees notice.


The biggest mistake? Rewarding disengagement with more work for everyone else.

This is how regrettable retention becomes a retention problem for the people you actually want to keep.

A low performer contributes less.

The work still needs to happen.

So who receives it?

Usually the reliable employee.

The capable employee.

The employee who always says yes.

Eventually the message becomes:

High performance earns you more work. Low performance earns you protection from difficult work.

Very few cultures survive that message for long.


Retention is not the goal. Contribution is.

The corporate world has spent years treating low turnover as an automatic sign of success.

But the future of talent management requires something more sophisticated.

The objective should not be to keep every employee indefinitely.

It should be to create an organisation where people can:

perform, grow, contribute and move forward.

Some will grow within the same role.

Some will move internally.

Some will need support.

Some will eventually leave.

And occasionally, the organisation should be comfortable with that.

Because a healthy workforce is not one where nobody leaves.

It is one where the people who stay still have a reason to care.


The question leaders should be asking

Stop asking only:

“How many people did we retain this year?”

Ask instead:

Who is growing?

Who is performing?

Who has stopped learning?

Who wants to stay?

Who is staying because they see a future here — and who is staying because they have nowhere else to go?

And perhaps the most uncomfortable question of all:

If your most disengaged employees are staying, what is making your most engaged employees want to stay too?

Because the biggest talent risk may no longer be the resignation you receive on Monday morning.

It may be the employee who stopped caring months ago —

and never resigned at all.

Print
Login